Why Oil is More Than Just a Lubricant: The Role of Honing, Ring Seal, and Surface Finish in Modern Engines

Why Oil is More Than Just a Lubricant: The Role of Honing, Ring Seal, and Surface Finish in Modern Engines

Oil is more than just a lubricant—it's the gasket between the piston ring and cylinder wall. In this deep technical dive, SPEEDiagnostix's Lake Speed Jr., Digital Metrology's Mark Malburg, and others explore how surface finish, piston ring design, and fuel type all influence engine sealing and performance.

Contrary to common belief, the piston ring doesn't make full contact with the cylinder wall; instead, it rides on a film of oil. This makes the oil itself a critical sealing component. However, this oil film can be compromised by fuel dilution, especially in engines running on alcohol-based fuels like methanol. Methanol aggressively washes oil from the walls, which can degrade sealing, increase blow-by, and reduce engine longevity. Same goes for ethanol enriched fuels.

To combat this, builders have turned to advanced honing techniques and surface metrology. New strategies focus on increasing valley depth in the cylinder wall finish to retain more oil and ensure consistent ring sealing. Using cutting-edge profilometer technology, engineers can now visualize and quantify these microscopic valleys and plateaus, enabling precise control over oil retention and ring seating.

Testing has shown that by optimizing surface finish and reducing piston-to-wall clearance—especially with thinner, low-drag ring packages—engines can gain significant power and longevity. In fact, NASCAR short blocks now last over 1,500 race miles, more than tripling their service life compared to older configurations.

Understanding Surface Finish: Why One Size Doesn't Fit All

The ideal surface finish for cylinder bores isn't universal—it must be tailored to the bore material, ring pack, and lubricant chemistry. Whether you're working with cast iron, Nikasil, Alusil, or other hypereutectic aluminum bores, each requires a specific texture to balance oil retention, wear resistance, and ring seating behavior.

Cast Iron Bores

Cast iron bores typically respond well to a multi-step honing process that generates a clear crosshatch and a combination of deep valleys and a smooth plateau. Values such as:

• Ra (Roughness Average): 10–20 µin

• Rk (Core Roughness): optimized for load-bearing

• Rv (Valley Depth): critical for oil retention
  are routinely targeted.

Nikasil and Other Plated Bores

Nikasil (nickel-silicon carbide) bores are incredibly hard and require diamond abrasives to achieve the desired surface. The finish must be fine enough to prevent ring wear, but rough enough to retain oil. These typically have:

• Ra: 4–10 µin

• Rv: carefully controlled to retain minimal oil while preventing washout

• Minimal Rpk (Reduced Peak Height) to avoid high contact stress

Alusil and Other Hypereutectic Aluminum Bores

These bores are etched to expose the silicon particles that support ring wear. Too rough a finish can damage rings; too smooth can lead to inadequate oil retention. The honing process is designed to preserve silicon protrusion, and thus:

• Ra: often in the 6–12 µin range

• Rk family of values become critical to define the plateau-to-valley ratio

• Use of non-abrasive profilometers is essential to prevent measurement errors from soft aluminum matrix material

---

How Surface Finish Is Verified

Surface finish is typically measured using a profilometer—a precision tool that drags a stylus across the bore surface to measure its vertical deviations. This is translated into a 2D or even 3D profile. Key values assessed include:

• Ra: Arithmetic average of surface roughness

• Rz: Mean peak-to-valley height

• Rk family: Parameters such as Rpk, Rk, and Rvk, which evaluate the peak, core, and valley zones of the surface

• Material ratio (MR or TPc): Shows how much of the bore surface is load-bearing at a given depth

Some engine builders now go beyond simple Ra values and evaluate bearing area curves, skewness, and kurtosis, which provide deeper insights into how the surface will retain oil and wear over time.

How Tuning Impacts Ring Seal, Lubrication, and Cylinder Longevity

Engine tuning plays a critical role in how well the entire ring sealing system functions. While modern fuels and lubricants are engineered to work together, improper tuning—particularly running excessively rich air-fuel ratios—can quickly undermine this balance.

The Problem with Overfueling: Fuel Washdown

When an engine is over-fueled, either through aggressive fuel maps, cold start enrichment, or faulty injectors, unburned fuel washes down the cylinder walls. This process dilutes and strips away the vital oil film that acts as the gasket between the piston rings and the bore surface.

This fuel dilution causes multiple problems:

• Loss of Lubrication: With the oil film disrupted, there's direct metal-to-metal contact, leading to ring and cylinder wear.

• Decreased Viscosity: Diluted oil thins out, reducing its ability to carry load, cool, and seal.

• Increased Blow-By: Poor ring seal allows combustion gases to escape into the crankcase, contaminating oil further and raising crankcase pressure.

• Accelerated Wear: On startup or under load, unlubricated cylinder walls wear rapidly, especially if surface finish was designed for optimal oil retention that’s now compromised.

This effect is exacerbated on aluminum bores, such as those found in Nikasil, Alusil, SUMEbore (APS), or plasma arc sprayed (PTWA) coatings. These surfaces rely heavily on a retained oil film in microscopic valleys—once that film is gone, rapid wear can occur even on hardened coatings.

Tuning Responsibly for Longevity

Tuning isn’t just about making more power—it’s about doing so without compromising engine health. That includes:

• Ensuring the air-fuel ratio stays within optimal ranges (typically 12.5–13.0:1 for NA engines under load; richer only if the application demands it, e.g., turbocharged engines with E85).

• Monitoring injector duty cycles and fuel trims to avoid unintentional enrichment.

• Using tools like used oil analysis to detect fuel dilution early—a spike in fuel percentage (>1% on port injected engines for example) is a red flag.

• Using complete fuel system treatments with PEA, like Driven Injector Defender, every 2-3k miles to ensure your injectors are operating correctly.

Cold Starts and Idling: Silent Killers

Even with a good tune under load, extended cold start idling on rich mixtures can cause washdown and dilution before the engine reaches operating temperature. In methanol or ethanol-fueled engines, which are inherently wetter, this is even more critical—the oil’s job as a gasket is compromised if it's being chemically washed away before the engine even sees wide-open throttle.

This shift toward data-driven honing and ring design has opened new frontiers in engine durability, friction reduction, and sealing efficiency. It’s not just about making horsepower—it's about retaining it, cleanly and efficiently, lap after lap.